Thursday, June 16, 2005

Jewish graveyards attacked in the UK - Independent

Two stories from today's Indie, the first (I think) the leading article. Copied here in their entirety as the Indie makes them pay-per-view a day or two after publication.

The shocking face of anti-Semitism
At a West Ham cemetery yesterday: the 117th attack on a Jewish graveyard in 15 years
The Independent
16 June 2005

The graves of the two children - Rachel, aged 13, and Abraham, aged four and a half - had stood undisturbed side by side for almost 150 years. But yesterday their headstones lay smashed, the Hebrew inscriptions, etched on fine Portland stone, crumbling in the dust.

Only yards away on an intricately crafted tomb, the words "Jew Boy Dead. Ha Ha" were scrawled in marker pen. Swastikas defaced the headstones of some of the 87 graves desecrated at West Ham cemetery in east London, where generations of Jews have been buried since the mid-19th century.

Vandals wreaked a trail of destruction, smashing and kicking over headstones in an act which has shocked the Jewish community. The main target of the attack appeared to be a grand circular mausoleum, built in the 19th century by the Rothschilds, one of Britain's most prominent Jewish families.

It is the latest in a rising number of racially motivated attacks on Jewish cemeteries across Britain. This was the 117th Jewish cemetery desecrated in Britain since 1990 and the third to be discovered in a week.

On the wall of the Rainham Jewish cemetery in Essex, it was discovered yesterday, two giant swastikas and the words "Yids out" had been daubed in paint. Last week, vandals smashed 100 gravestones in a historic cemetery in Manchester.

The desecration is part of a rise in anti-Semitic incidents in Britain, including violent attacks on children and orthodox Jews. There were 532 anti-Semitic incidents last year, the highest since records began 20 years ago.

Earlier this week, the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance said it was "concerned at the considerable and steady increase of anti-Semitic incidents in the United Kingdom."

"While these incidents usually mirror tensions in the Middle East, representatives of the Jewish communities report there now seems to be a higher level of background violence against these communities," the report by the European human rights watchdog said. "Although manifestations of anti-Semitism continue to come from extreme right-wing and neo-Nazi groups, an increasing number ... is reportedly coming from Muslim fundamentalist groups," the report said.

"It has now regrettably become commonplace to desecrate Jewish cemeteries," said a spokesman for the Community Security Trust, which offers security advice to the Jewish community. "These acts must be treated seriously by the police and the judiciary should pass deterrent sentences in these cases."

Melvyn Hartog, head of burials for the United synagogues, was picking his way yesterday through the mess of graves in West Ham. Standing before the broken headstones of children, he said: "Tell me what these kids have done to people? These are dead kids. They can't fight back. This is the greatest form of cowardice you'll find."

The circular tomb, designed for the Rothschilds by Matthew Digby Wyatt, the architect of the India office in Whitehall, had its door battered in with iron bars, ripped from the sides of tombs.

The 4th Baron Rothschild was said to be aware of the desecration but declined to comment.

Police visited the cemetery and removed items for forensic examination. Detective Inspector Steve Lane, of Newham police, described the vandalism as "a despicable racist attack" and asked anyone with information to come forward.

A clue to the identity of the those responsible was found on the side of an elegant mausoleum, where the words "A Hitler" and several swastikas were scrawled. A number of graffiti "tags", including "snow-man and Greedy" were scribbled alongside, suggesting that teenagers were involved. The scrawled swastikas were the wrong way round.

Members of the Jewish community said they had no doubt the motive was anti-Semitic. Directly next door to the Jewish cemetery is a communal graveyard that was left untouched.

-----------------------


Defaced, the Rothschild mausoleum that has stood for 140 years
The Independent
16 June 2005

The Rothschild mausoleum - the centrepiece of West Ham Jewish Cemetery - is a memorial to the tragic end of the brief but intense happiness that two of the family found at the height of the dynasty's fortunes as the kings of European banking.

When Evelina ("Evy") Rothschild (daughter of Lionel Rothschild, founder of NM Rothschild bank in London) married her cousin Ferdinand Rothschild, the son of Baron Anselm Rothschild (head of the bank in Vienna), in 1865 they formed a notably happy union.

The wedding took place at Evy's parents' mansion in Piccadilly. Benjamin Disraeli, who gave the wedding toast, found Ferdinand "a most fascinating youth". From their honeymoon, Evy wrote to her parents that she found Ferdinand "a dear old duck" (they were both 26).

In 1865 the Rothschild family was at the height of its fortunes. Just 50 years after making an international reputation their name was a byword for solid worth in world banking. Before the rise of the great American financial combines and the London clearing banks, Rothschild ruled the roost in Europe, having overtaken Barings and Hottinguers as the biggest international lenders.

The huge cousinage that spread across Europe were great patrons of architecture and collectors of art and antiquities. Ferdinand and Evy's honeymoon was as much a tour of the family empire as a celebration of their union. They returned to London at the end of the year and set up house in Piccadilly, a few doors down from her parents. After a wholesome summer holiday at Scarborough, surrounded by relations, Evy returned to London to await the birth of her first child. The boy was stillborn on 4 December 1866 and Evy died later the same day.

The shock in the family was intense. Evy's cousin Constance recorded in her diary "coming up to London and reading that terrible message in the paper. It was enough to arrive all trembling with fear and anguish. The house, all dark and shut up, confirmed our unhappy fear. And then, the sight of the mourners - oh, it went to my heart. Saw the bedroom, that gay, bright room with the motionless form on the bed, with the poor, tiny baby on the sofa. Oh, what a sight."

The mausoleum in West Ham was built to house Evy's remains. Ferdinand also built, equipped and endowed the Evelina Hospital for children in Southwark, south London, in her memory. The hospital, with 100 beds, was the most modern of its day.

Ferdinand, in the family tradition of grand philanthropy, also became a benefactor of the Hospital for Consumptives in Brompton Road, west London, and St George's Hospital, Hyde Park Corner, in central London.

In the remaining 30 years of his life as a politician - he was MP for Aylesbury, and an intimate of Gladstone and the Prince of Wales - and an avid art collector. He never remarried and dedicated his life (including the building of Waddesdon, the great mansion in Buckinghamshire) to his wife's memory.

After his father's death in 1874 he had the wherewithal not only to build Waddesdon, but to fill it with French furniture, a collection of Sèvres porcelain and the best of English portraits by Romney, Gainsborough and Reynolds. After Ferdinand's death in 1898 his Rothschild heirs kept on the house until it was given to the National Trust by Mr and Mrs Jimmy de Rothschild. When Dolly de Rothschild died in 1990, leaving the largest will proved in Britain to that date, the family interest in the house passed to Evy's great great nephew Jacob Rothschild, the present Baron Rothschild, whose continuing investment in the house was highlighted in a recent documentary series on the National Trust. The house suffered a burglary at the time of the making of this documentary. Many of the snuffboxes collected by Ferdinand and his father were lost.

When Ferdinand died in 1898 he was buried by his wife in their mausoleum in West Ham - the woman, he wrote, who "had so grown into my heart that my only wishes, cares, joys, affections, whatever sentiments in fact a man possesses were directly or indirectly wound with her existence".

Under attack

MARCH 2004: AGECROFT CEMETERY, SALFORD
A Jewish gravestone is covered in black paint, defaced with a black marker pen and repeatedly hit with a brick.

JUNE 2004: LINTHORPE CEMETERY, MIDDLESBROUGH
A total of 68 gravestones are pushed over and smashed in an attack on the Jewish quarter of the historic cemetery.

AUGUST 2004: WITTON CEMETERY, BIRMINGHAM
Two men smash or push over about 60 graves and are charged with racially aggravated offences.

SEPTEMBER 2004: DALSTON ROAD CEMETERY, CARLISLE
Swastikas and SS signs are carved into the headstone of a Jewish grave.

NOVEMBER 2004: REDAN ROAD CEMETERY, ALDERSHOT, HAMPSHIRE
Fifteen headstones are defaced with swastikas, SS signs and other Nazi insignia.

JANUARY 2005: REDAN ROAD CEMETERY, ALDERSHOT, HAMPSHIRE
Two months later, the same cemetery is attacked, one grave is daubed with C18 - the name of a far-right militant group.

JUNE 2005: RAINSOUGH JEWISH CEMETERY, PRESTWICH, MANCHESTER
About 100 headstones are vandalised, including the graves of Holocaust survivors, in the ninth attack on the cemetery in a decade.

JUNE 2005: WEST HAM CEMETERY, EAST LONDON
The doors of a mausoleum at the cemetery are forced open, 87 gravestones are vandalised, some with painted swastikas.

1 comment:

dan said...

Apparently it's all Israel's fault:

" Hate crimes and images of Israel

Sir Your graphic report (16 June) on the rising incidence of anti-Semitism in the UK mirrors that of Europe generally. However, the obscene desecration of Jewish cemeteries is more usually an act of juvenile vandalism that is not, in fact, inspired by anti-Semitism. That anti-Semitism is real and rising, however, is not in question and there is an imperative for more meaningful discussion as to how to counteract such anti-Jewish feeling in the face of Israeli intransigence in the Middle East.

When olive groves belonging to Palestinian Arabs living at subsidence level are uprooted by the IDF, on the pretence of security, it immediately fuels anti-Semitic sentiment around the world. That there is a direct connection between these two should not be in question. Israel is not an obscure island and her government must be more aware of the serious consequences of her actions, in particular, to those Jewish communities overseas who, in general, support her.

Anti-Semitism - the oldest prejudice - will unfortunately never be eradicated in its entirety, but Israel has an absolute responsibility and duty to the majority of world Jewry (75 per cent) who live outside its shores and whose future is entirely dependent on the goodwill of the host countries in which they live.

MICHAEL HALPERN

WESTBOURNE, DORSET"

And an opposing view:

"Sir: Your judgement that a splash report is needed for the latest gravestone smashing anti-Semitism might trigger your reconsideration of the disingenuous manner of your reporting the Arab vendetta with Israel these last decades.

It is quite impossible to keep up a campaign against Israel that studiously does not explain that the dispute stems from Arab defiance of UN partition policy - not only of 181 in 1947, but ever since - and then expect that no social trash and no cynics will take such an atmosphere as the green light for violent words and violent misbehaviour.

FRANK ADAM
PRESTWICH, GREATER MANCHESTER"

http://comment.independent.co.uk/letters/story.jsp?story=647362